Piece	Set	State	Verdict	Model	Why	When
pin-hero	—	rejected	reject human	gemini-flash-image	Superseded 2026-09-06: docade's row moved 320 -> 640. Same reason as its pair — these two are judged together or not at all.	2026-09-04
pin-hero	—	rejected	reject human	gemini-flash-image	Superseded 2026-09-06: docade's row moved 320 -> 640. Same reason as its pair — these two are judged together or not at all.	2026-09-04
join-hero	—	rejected	reject human	gemini-flash-image	Superseded 2026-09-06: docade's row moved 480 -> 640 after this was promoted. The art is correct and the SIZE contract it was judged against no longer exists. ⚠ It was promoted rather than approved, and resolveCurrent ranks state before recency — so a promoted exemplar outranks a newer approved re-render and stayed current at delivery, blocking the 640 pair with 'the client's manifest declares 640px'. Promote is stickier than approve and nothing says so at the point it bites.	2026-09-04
join-hero	—	rejected	reject human	gemini-flash-image	Superseded 2026-09-06: docade's row moved 480 -> 640 after this was promoted. The art is correct and the SIZE contract it was judged against no longer exists. ⚠ It was promoted rather than approved, and resolveCurrent ranks state before recency — so a promoted exemplar outranks a newer approved re-render and stayed current at delivery, blocking the 640 pair with 'the client's manifest declares 640px'. Promote is stickier than approve and nothing says so at the point it bites.	2026-09-04
pin-hero	—	rejected	reject human	gemini-flash-image	pin-hero superseded by r-20260904-70f1 — did not share a room with join-hero, and they are consecutive screens seconds apart.	2026-09-04
pin-hero	—	rejected	reject human	gemini-flash-image	pin-hero superseded by r-20260904-70f1 — did not share a room with join-hero, and they are consecutive screens seconds apart.	2026-09-04
join-hero	—	rejected	reject human	gemini-flash-image	join-hero superseded by r-20260904-280a — came back a dark room with a little light in it, which is atmospheric and the wrong feeling for an invitation, and reached for the brand gradient that belongs to splash-hero alone.	2026-09-04
join-hero	—	rejected	reject human	gemini-flash-image	join-hero superseded by r-20260904-280a — came back a dark room with a little light in it, which is atmospheric and the wrong feeling for an invitation, and reached for the brand gradient that belongs to splash-hero alone.	2026-09-04